VAT Penalties
How VAT penalties work under the points-based system that started in January 2023, and how to avoid surcharges.
Articles
VAT late filing penalties
Since January 2023, late VAT returns work on a points-based system. Here is how points accumulate and when they trigger a £200 penalty.
VAT late payment penalties
VAT late payment penalties stack from day 16, increase again from day 31, and can continue daily until the VAT is paid.
Late returns: points, then penalties
Each late VAT return earns one penalty point. Reach the threshold (four points on quarterly returns, five on monthly, two on annual) and HMRC charges £200, then another £200 for every further late return while you stay at the threshold.
Points expire after two years if you stay under the threshold; at the threshold, only a full clean streak resets them: twelve months of on-time returns for quarterly filers, with everything older also filed. Nil and repayment returns count: late is late regardless of the money.
Late payment: the 15-and-30-day structure
Pay within 15 days of the due date (or arrange Time to Pay within them): no penalty. Between 16 and 30 days: a first penalty accrues on the amount outstanding. Past 30 days: it doubles in weight, and a second, annualised penalty runs daily until payment. Interest runs from day one throughout, separately.
The whole regime is a speed incentive. The difference between day 14 and day 31 on a meaningful VAT bill is real money.
Inaccuracy penalties apply to VAT too
Errors on VAT returns fall under the same behaviour-based regime as other taxes: nothing for reasonable care, up to 30% of the understated VAT for carelessness, more for deliberate conduct, with large reductions for unprompted disclosure.
Small net errors within the limits can be corrected on the next return; bigger or deliberate ones need separate disclosure. Correcting your own errors promptly is the cheapest compliance work there is.
Appealing VAT penalties
Points and penalties both carry appeal rights: 30 days, in writing, on reasonable-excuse or factual grounds (the return was not late; the point was wrongly counted; the percentage was misapplied). The statutory review route and tribunal sit behind HMRC's first answer, as with any penalty.
For RR VAT clients this section is mostly academic: returns are prepared, reviewed, and filed inside the window through Deadline Lock, and the points ledger stays at zero, which is the only place it is worth keeping.
Frequently asked questions
How many late VAT returns before I'm fined?
On quarterly returns, the fourth late one triggers the first £200 penalty, and every late return after that is £200 more until a twelve-month clean streak resets the points. Monthly filers reach it at five points, annual at two.
Do penalty points expire?
Individual points expire after roughly two years, but only while you are below the threshold. Once at the threshold, expiry stops and only the full clean streak (plus all outstanding returns filed) clears the slate.
Is there a penalty if I file late but owe nothing?
A late nil or repayment return still earns a penalty point, and points are what convert into £200 charges. The filing regime looks only at timeliness, never the amount.
I paid 20 days late. What has it cost?
Daily interest from the due date, plus the first late-payment penalty on the amount that was still outstanding at day 15, but not the heavier past-30-day layer. Paying before day 31, or arranging Time to Pay, is what stops the escalation.